The Bay Area Stopped Building. Renters Are Paying 9% More for It.

The Bay Area Stopped Building. Renters Are Paying 9% More. Header image by Daniel Kaufman
The Bay Area Stopped Building. Renters Are Paying 9% More.

Bay Area apartment asking rents are up 9% from a year ago, against 1.3% nationally, according to CoStar data reported by GlobeSt and summarized by CRE Daily this week. That is roughly seven times the national pace, and it is not a demand miracle. It is arithmetic.

Over twelve months the region delivered fewer than 2,000 apartments while renters absorbed more than 7,000, according to Northmarq’s Andrew Slaton in the same coverage. New construction is moving at about one sixth of the national rate. In Mountain View and Los Altos, vacancy sits near 3%, rents rose 8.7%, and only about 225 units are being built.

What happened

Capital noticed. CRE Daily reported that New York Life provided a $105 million, five year, interest only refinancing on the 272 unit Madrone Apartments in Mountain View, about two miles from Google’s headquarters. The lender gave credit for eight planned accessory dwelling units that will take the property to 280 homes. Even so, Slaton said yields rose more than 50 basis points between underwriting and rate lock, which squeezed proceeds.

The hotel side tells the same story from another angle. CoStar data cited by CRE Daily shows San Francisco hotel occupancy reached 80.4% in September, with RevPAR up 17.9% to $224.45 and average daily rate at $279.05, carried by conventions and AI events. The city has still regained only 85% of its 2019 RevPAR, the weakest of the 174 markets CoStar tracks, and its room count fell by 373 to 54,894 in a year.

Where we see opportunity

The Bay Area is a preview of what the national supply trough does to rents. CRE Daily reported that new apartment supply is set to fall 22% in 2026 to 513,883 units and bottom near 450,964 in 2027. The markets that stop building first feel it first.

The opportunity is not in chasing the rent number. It is in the small, entitled additions that owners can actually get done: accessory units on underused parking and yard space, infill on land that is already zoned, and conversions where the existing shell is cheaper than new steel. Madrone’s lender underwrote eight future units. That is the signal. Incremental density on land you already control is the fastest supply in a market that cannot build fast.

It is also a workforce housing story. The convention, hotel and service workers who staff an AI driven event calendar are the ones absorbing a 9% rent increase. Employer anchored housing near job centers is where we see durable demand, and it is the thinking behind Haven, our attainable and workforce housing brand.

Where we see the downfalls

First, concentration. Rent growth this strong in a region whose demand leans so heavily on one industry is a bet that the industry keeps hiring. If AI payrolls cool, the absorption math can flip quickly.

Second, rent growth this fast invites a policy response, and California has never been shy about one. Underwriting that assumes the curve continues is also underwriting the politics.

Third, rates. CRE Daily’s market snapshot showed the 10 year Treasury at 5.00% at the November 10 close, after October’s hot inflation report. The Madrone squeeze shows that a strong rent story can still lose proceeds to the bond market between the handshake and the closing.

Fourth, the hotel recovery is incomplete. SF Travel projects roughly 72% occupancy in 2027 against about 82% in 2019, per CoStar via CRE Daily, because international travel has not come back.

What we are watching

Whether the handful of Bay Area projects delivering over the next year dent rent growth, how many owners follow Madrone and add units through accessory dwellings, whether AI hiring keeps pace with rents, and where the 10 year settles after the December Fed meeting.

If you own land or an existing property in a supply constrained market and want to know what can realistically be added and what it would cost, a Site and Feasibility Review from Kaufman Real Estate & Consulting is a practical first step: https://www.kaufmanrealestateandconsulting.com

About the Author

I’m the founder and CEO of Kaufman & Company, a permanent capital holding company that buys land and existing assets across multifamily, hotels, resorts, industrial, commercial, mixed use, AI infrastructure and data centers, and builds and holds them for the long term. My focus is workforce housing and employer-anchored development, including mountain resort communities.

Reach me at Daniel@kaufmanredev.com or find more at danielkaufmanre.com.

Sources

Bay Area Multifamily Rents Rise 9%, 7x the National Pace, CRE Daily, November 10, 2026, https://www.credaily.com/briefs/bay-area-multifamily-rents-rise-9-7x-the-national-pace/

San Francisco Hotel Recovery Gains Steam, Still Lags 2019, CRE Daily, November 10, 2026, https://www.credaily.com/briefs/san-francisco-hotel-recovery-gains-steam-still-lags-2019/

Rate Swings Stall Deals as CRE Brokerages Cut Q4 Forecasts, CRE Daily, November 12, 2026, https://www.credaily.com/newsletters/national/issue/rate-swings-stall-deals-as-cre-brokerages-cut-q4-forecasts/

About Daniel Kaufman

Daniel Kaufman is the Principal and CEO of Kaufman & Company, a real estate development and investment platform spanning residential development, workforce housing, AI infrastructure, and venture capital, with more than 25 years in the industry. Learn more about his work at thekaufmanco.com and danielkaufmanre.com.

Leave a Reply